Find the Best Home and Car Insurance Agents in Norman,Oklahoma

Our top 19 list features verified, licensed insurance agent professionals. Rankings are based on human research, insurance verification, and public record audits.

Top 19 Insurance Agents in Norman

Verified professionals ranked by our comprehensive research methodology

#1
logo for Rightway Insurance
Verified

Rightway Insurance

SponsoredLocally Owned

Rightway Insurance is an independent insurance agency based in Oklahoma, providing personal and business insurance solutions. As independent agents, they represent multiple carriers, allowing clients to compare and choose the best coverage for auto, home, life, and business needs. They focus on education and a one-on-one service approach to ensure a positive customer experience.

Pros

  • Independent agency model allows access to multiple carriers for competitive pricing.

Cons

  • Limited public review data on major third-party platforms like Yelp or BBB for the Moore location.
Review Scores
FacebookNot rated
Google5.0
#2
logo for Garner Insurance
Verified

Garner Insurance

Garner Insurance is an Independent Insurance Agency servicing the Norman area and throughout Oklahoma. They offer personal insurance coverages such as auto, boat & watercraft, condo, flood, and homeowners insurance, as well as business insurance coverages including bonds, builders risk, business owners policy, church insurance, and commercial auto.

Pros

  • Independent agency providing access to multiple insurance carriers

Cons

  • No contact email readily available on the site
#3
logo for Steiner Insurance Group
Verified

Steiner Insurance Group

Independent

Steiner Insurance Group in Norman, OK, provides insurance protection for personal injury or loss of property, offering coverage for home, auto, life, commercial, and other policies suited to budgets and lifestyles. They serve residents in Norman and surrounding communities with various insurance types including auto, home, commercial, and umbrella.

Pros

  • Over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry

Cons

  • Business hours not published which may confuse clients
#4
logo for Oklahoma Insurance Group
Verified

Oklahoma Insurance Group

Oklahoma Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency based in Norman, Oklahoma, that shops and compares insurance options to find the best combination of cost and coverage for personal and commercial needs.

Pros

  • Independent agency comparing options from multiple carriers

Cons

  • No published hours which can be confusing for clients
#5
logo for Allied Insurance Agency
Verified

Allied Insurance Agency

Allied Insurance Agency works with you to understand your unique insurance needs. They’ll follow up with many fine insurance providers to deliver high-quality, affordable insurance options tailored to deliver the value and coverage you’re seeking.

Pros

  • Locally owned and operated for over 35 years

Cons

  • Very antiquated website
#6
logo for Fairway Insurance Group, LLC
Verified

Fairway Insurance Group, LLC

Independent

Independent insurance agency offering auto, home, commercial, and workers' compensation insurance services in the Norman area.

Pros

  • Independent agency providing competitive quotes from multiple carriers.

Cons

  • Relatively new agency compared to long-established competitors.
#7
logo for Knights Insurance Agency
Verified

Knights Insurance Agency

Independent insurance agency that works with multiple companies to provide the best coverage at competitive prices, with over 36 years of experience, focusing on superior customer service and small business insurance.

Pros

  • Over 36 years of experience in the insurance industry.

Cons

  • No office hours on Friday
#8
logo for Jim Holmes Insurance
Verified

Jim Holmes Insurance

Independent

Independent insurance agency providing affordable insurance quotes and coverage to individuals and businesses in the area, shopping multiple carriers for the best policy options, offering practical solutions, excellent service, and assistance in navigating policy choices.

Pros

  • Family-owned since 1956, providing long-standing experience and personalized service.

Cons

  • Limited media presence
#9
logo for Buffalo Insurance
Verified

Buffalo Insurance

Independent

Provides personal and commercial insurance tailored to the everyday needs of Oklahomans, serving Norman, Moore, Oklahoma City, Edmond and beyond. Committed to using 30 years of experience to offer coverage at satisfactory rates, with a focus on community giving and reliable customer service. Offers commercial insurance policies including general liability, commercial auto, commercial excess, inland marine, business owners, workers compensation, surety bonds, and commercial buildings. Provides personal insurance policies such as homeowners, landlord, renters, automotive, motorcycle, boat, recreational vehicle, and umbrella coverage.

Pros

  • 30 years of business experience providing tailored insurance solutions.

Cons

  • Scarce media presence online
#10
logo for Brian McPherson - Shelter Insurance
Verified

Brian McPherson - Shelter Insurance

Shelter

As your Shelter agent, my job is to help you find the types of coverage you need to protect what matters most to you-your family, your home, your vehicles and more. I look forward to helping you get the right coverage at the right price and providing the outstanding service you expect.

Pros

  • Experienced agent with over 12 years in the insurance industry, including claims, consulting, and sales

Cons

  • Smaller office may be noticeable compared to larger agencies
#11
logo for J Charles Insurance
Verified

J Charles Insurance

Independent

J Charles Insurance offers personal and commercial insurance services across America, focusing on authenticity, honesty, and transparency while providing exceptional service and tailored solutions for clients' needs.

Pros

  • Independent agency with wide variety of insurance solutions

Cons

  • Not part of a unified brand if customers want that
#12
logo for Greg Ellis - State Farm
Verified

Greg Ellis - State Farm

State Farm

State Farm Insurance Agent offering auto, home, life, health, pet insurance, banking, and investment services in Norman. Greg Ellis has been a State Farm representative in Norman for over 12 years.

Pros

  • 35 years of State Farm experience.

Cons

  • Some customers report issues with claims processing.
#13
logo for Cindy Nashert - State Farm
Verified

Cindy Nashert - State Farm

State Farm

State Farm Insurance Agent offering auto, home, life, health, pet, business insurance, with focus on commercial in Norman. Cindy Nashert has represented State Farm in Norman for a long time and has a great reputation in the community.

Pros

  • Experienced agent since 2000, affiliated since 1989.

Cons

  • Smaller office and representative staff
#14
logo for Julia Chew - State Farm
Verified

Julia Chew - State Farm

State Farm

State Farm Insurance Agent offering auto, home, life, health, renters, and business insurance, as well as financial products including banking, investment services, and annuities. Julia Chew has been a State Farm representative for Norman for over 2 decades.

Pros

  • Long-term customer relationships, with clients staying for over a decade due to excellent care.

Cons

  • State Farm often difficult with roofing claims.
#15
logo for Brandon Fisher - AllState
Verified

Brandon Fisher - AllState

AllState

Local Allstate Insurance Agent offering auto, home, condo, renters, motorcycle, business, life, ATV, and boat insurance. Committed to helping residents assess needs and achieve goals with personalized service.

Pros

  • Wide variety of insurance products including auto, home, life, and more.

Cons

  • Not accredited by the Better Business Bureau.
#16
logo for Elise Stansel - AllState
Verified

Elise Stansel - AllState

AllState

Elise Stansel is a second-generation insurance agent who opened her agency in Norman, OK in 2017. She graduated from the University of Central Oklahoma in 2008 with a degree in interior design and a minor in art history. Her agency offers a range of insurance products including auto, home, condo, renters, motorcycle, business, life, ATV, and boat insurance. The agency emphasizes honesty, integrity, and outstanding customer service, with a motto of \“To professionally sell and service insurance to meet our insureds’ needs\” since 1990. Elise is passionate about helping the Norman community, volunteering for Allstate grants, and supporting organizations like Southcentral CASA, Women’s Resource Center, and the YWCA in Oklahoma City. She is a member of the Norman Chamber, Norman Next, Norman Board of Realtors, and Oklahoma City Hispanic Chamber. The agency team includes licensed agents and producers focused on tailoring coverage to individual needs.

Pros

  • Wide range of insurance products offered

Cons

  • AllState widely known for being difficult in roofing claims
#17
logo for James Parker - State Farm
Verified

James Parker - State Farm

State Farm® Insurance Agent offering auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, pet insurance, banking, investment services, annuities. Assists with coverage for car, truck, SUV; homeowners & renters; life; health.

Pros

  • Active community involvement, such as supporting youth athletics and local events.

Cons

  • State Farm recently publicized about DEI policies
#18
logo for Irving Tovar - Farmers
Verified

Irving Tovar - Farmers

Farmers

Local Farmers Insurance agent helping customers identify insurance coverage that fits their needs, including Auto, Home, Renters, Life, and Business Insurance. Speaks English and Spanish.

Pros

  • Bilingual support in English and Spanish

Cons

  • Newcomer for Farmers Insurance Agency
#19
logo for Josh Nelson - AllState
Verified

Josh Nelson - AllState

AllState

Local Allstate Insurance Agent offering options for a wide variety of coverage and services, including auto, home, condo, renters, motorcycle, business, life, ATV, and boat insurance.

Pros

  • Fast response times to inquiries and efficient service

Cons

  • Limited to Allstate products as a captive agent, potentially missing broader market options